A cell-by-cell map of the aging ovary points to the cells around the eggs, and to one gene

By reading the active genes of hundreds of thousands of single cells from human ovaries, a team in China found that the cells that nurse the eggs change the most as women approach menopause. One gene in these cells, HEYL, held back signs of cell aging in lab dishes and flies. A small, not yet peer-reviewed study whose key experiments were done in cells and animals.

The ovaries age faster than most organs. Long before other parts of the body show their years, the supply of eggs dwindles and their quality declines, ending in menopause. Because the hormones the ovaries make also protect bones, blood vessels and perhaps the brain, how the ovary ages matters well beyond fertility.

A team at Zhejiang University School of Medicine in China has now built a detailed atlas of the human ovary at three stages: young, during the years leading up to menopause, and after it. The biggest changes were in granulosa cells, the cells that surround each egg, feed it and make hormones. The study, a preprint not yet peer-reviewed, also singles out one gene in these cells, HEYL, as a possible brake on their aging, though that part rests on lab experiments.

What they did

The team collected ovarian tissue from women having surgery for other reasons (only tissue that pathologists confirmed was free of tumours). Donors were grouped by age, menstrual history and the level of FSH, a hormone that rises as the ovary ages.

  • Single-cell profiling. For five donors per group, the team read which genes were switched on in each individual cell, and in a separate experiment which stretches of DNA were open and accessible, a clue to which genes a cell is ready to use. In total they analysed about 183,000 cells for gene activity and about 130,000 for DNA accessibility.
  • Spatial mapping. One tissue section per group was analysed in a way that keeps track of where in the tissue each signal comes from.
  • Genetics. They compared their results with large genetic studies of the age at natural menopause.
  • Lab tests. They then turned the HEYL gene down or up in a human cell line that behaves like granulosa cells, in granulosa cells from mice, and in the ovaries of fruit flies. They also measured HEYL in granulosa cells collected from 29 women during IVF treatment, 14 younger and 15 aged 35 or older.

What they found

  • Granulosa cells changed the most. They became scarcer with age, while smooth-muscle cells became more common. Among all cell types, granulosa cells had the largest number of genes whose activity shifted with age.
  • The transition years had their own signature. In the run-up to menopause, granulosa cells showed lower activity of genes for DNA repair and higher activity of stress-response genes. Cells in a state linked to the death of follicles (the fluid-filled sacs that hold the eggs) were already more common at this stage.
  • Hormone programmes faded. DNA regions used by proteins that drive hormone production became less accessible with age, while regions linked to cell stress opened up.
  • HEYL stood out. This gene is especially active in granulosa cells, and a stretch of DNA that probably controls it became less accessible with age. HEYL activity was lower in granulosa cells from the IVF patients aged 35 or older, and in cells from old mice. Genetic variation in or near HEYL and several genes that control it was linked to the age at menopause.
  • In lab tests, HEYL held back cell aging. Turning HEYL down made more granulosa-like cells show markers of senescent cells (cells that have stopped dividing and send out inflammatory signals). Turning it up partly protected cells from senescence caused by hydrogen peroxide, a chemical that causes oxidative damage. The fly version of the gene had similar effects in fly ovaries.

What to keep in mind

  • Few donors. Five women per group for the main analyses, and a single tissue section per group for the spatial map. The transition-stage section held so few granulosa cells that it could not be used for the granulosa analyses.
  • Different kinds of samples. Young tissue came mostly from small biopsies, older tissue mostly from removed ovaries, which the authors note may have affected the cell counts. The eggs themselves were not captured.
  • Associations within the atlas. Gene activity and DNA accessibility were measured in different cells, so the gene networks linking them are predictions that, the authors say, need further validation.
  • HEYL's role is shown only in a dish and in flies. The authors write that its effects on ovarian function and reproductive lifespan in living mammals "remain to be established".
  • Not yet peer-reviewed.

Why it matters

Most earlier atlases of the aging ovary lumped women in their forties and fifties together. By separating the transition years from the years after menopause, this study suggests that important changes in granulosa cells, including weaker DNA repair, start before periods stop. It adds to recent posts on the postmenopausal ovary and a small rapamycin trial aimed at slowing ovarian aging. HEYL is one candidate among several; whether supporting it could delay ovarian aging in women is an open question that this work does not answer.