In older adults, the waves of brain fluid that roll in during deep sleep are much weaker
Scanning people while they slept in an MRI machine, researchers found that the slow waves of fluid that wash through the brain during deep sleep were far weaker in healthy older adults than in young ones. Both weaker brain waves and stiffer blood-vessel responses seemed to play a part. A careful study in 72 people, but it did not measure whether waste removal itself suffers.
Our brains float in a clear liquid, cerebrospinal fluid (CSF), which cushions them and carries substances out of brain tissue. In young adults, something striking happens during deep sleep: large, slow waves of this fluid surge in and out of the brain, about once every 20 seconds. Many researchers think this helps the brain clean itself at night.
A team at MIT and Boston University has now shown that in healthy older adults these sleep-time fluid waves are much weaker. The study compared two age groups at one point in time and measured fluid movement, not cleaning itself, so it describes a difference, not yet a consequence.
Why fluid moves during sleep
The skull is a closed box. When blood vessels in the brain widen, they take up more room and push fluid out; when they narrow, fluid flows back in. During deep, non-dreaming sleep (called NREM sleep), brain cells fire together in slow rhythms called slow waves, which an EEG (electrodes on the scalp) picks up. Earlier work in young people showed that these slow waves are followed by swings in blood volume, which in turn drive the fluid waves. Aging is known to bring lighter sleep with fewer slow waves, and stiffer blood vessels. Either could weaken the fluid flow.
What they did
Volunteers came in around midnight and tried to fall asleep inside an MRI scanner while wearing an EEG cap. A fast scanning method let the team measure two things at once: blood-related signals in the brain's grey matter, and fluid flowing into the fourth ventricle, one of the brain's fluid-filled cavities. After excluding people who never slept or moved too much, 31 young adults (average age 24) and 41 older adults (average age 69) were analysed. None had dementia, a sleep disorder or other neurological disease.
In separate daytime sessions, 31 young and 55 older adults did two tasks in the scanner. In one they watched a flickering checkerboard, which makes brain cells fire and blood flow increase. In the other they held their breath for 15 seconds at a time, which widens blood vessels directly. Together, the tasks let the team tell apart a weaker nerve signal from a weaker blood-vessel response.
What they found
- The fluid waves of sleep were much weaker in older adults. Young adults showed a clear rise in slow fluid flow when they fell asleep (an average increase of 3.82 decibels, a log measure of signal strength). In older adults the rise was only 1.15 decibels and was not statistically significant. Older adults also had somewhat less flow while awake, but the gap was largest during sleep.
- The blood-volume waves were weaker too, and in both age groups, people whose blood signal rose more during sleep also had more fluid flow. In older adults, the fluid followed the blood signal less closely than in the young.
- Fewer slow waves explained part of the loss. Older adults had less slow-wave activity in the front of the brain, and people with less slow-wave activity had less fluid flow. A statistical analysis suggested that age reduced fluid flow partly through fewer slow waves, and through the weaker blood waves that follow them. Even after accounting for both, age still had an effect of its own.
- The blood vessels themselves responded less. Older adults' brain cells responded to the flickering checkerboard as strongly as young adults', yet their blood flow and fluid flow responded less. Their vessels also widened less during breath-holding. In older adults, weaker daytime responses went together with weaker fluid flow during sleep that night.
- Less fluid flow went with less brain tissue. In older adults, those with weaker sleep-time fluid flow had less grey matter in the frontal lobe, the front part of the brain where slow waves are strongest. This link was not seen in the young.
- Not every older brain had changed. Some older participants had fluid flow and vessel responses similar to those of young adults.
What to keep in mind
- Waste clearance was not measured. The authors write that the consequences of weaker large-scale fluid flow for removing waste "are still not established". Headlines about a weaker "cleaning system" go one step beyond the data.
- A snapshot, not a follow-up. Young and old were compared once, so the study cannot show how flow changes in one person over the years, or whether weaker flow leads to brain shrinkage or the other way round. The authors list all three possibilities.
- A modest number of people, all healthy volunteers who could sleep in a loud scanner. Fluid flow was measured in one spot, the fourth ventricle, in one to three 25-minute recording runs per person, not over a full night in bed.
- Things not measured, which the authors name: blood pressure, blood volume in the brain, hydration, past sleep loss and genetic risk factors could all affect fluid flow.
Why it matters
Poor sleep in later life is linked to memory decline and dementia, and one popular idea is that the brain's night-time fluid flow is part of the reason. This study shows directly, in healthy people, that the fluid waves of deep sleep are weaker in older people, and points to two separate contributors: fewer slow brain waves, and blood vessels that respond less. Because the main problem can differ from person to person, the authors argue that any future attempt to restore fluid flow may need to be tailored, for example to sleep in some people and to blood vessels in others.