Older women's thigh muscle carries a protein pattern that tracks grip strength and walking speed

Muscle samples from 10 women in their twenties and 10 in their seventies and eighties showed a clear shift in which proteins the muscle contains, and a set of 24 proteins lined up closely with strength and walking speed. A small, early preprint that still needs testing in other groups.

With age, muscles lose strength faster than they lose size. That suggests the muscle tissue itself changes, not just the amount of it. Grip strength and walking speed are among the best simple predictors of health in older people, so researchers want to know what is going on inside the muscle when they decline. Most earlier studies of this kind looked mainly at men, or mixed men and women.

A team working within the US National Institutes of Health's network for mapping senescent cells (cells that have permanently stopped dividing and send out inflammatory signals) has now compared muscle from younger and older women. The study is a preprint: it has not yet been peer-reviewed.

What they did

Twenty healthy women had a small piece of thigh muscle removed with a biopsy needle: 10 aged 24 to 30 and 10 aged 70 to 84. None had major chronic diseases. Each woman also had her grip strength measured and did a 400-metre walking test.

The researchers then used proteomics, the large-scale measurement of proteins, to work out how much of about 2,400 different proteins each muscle sample contained. They looked for proteins that differed between the age groups and for ones that rose or fell with strength and walking speed.

What they found

  • The older women were weaker and slower. Their grip was about a third weaker on average (20.2 versus 30.8 kg), and they walked more slowly.
  • 163 proteins differed clearly between the groups. 95 were higher in the older women's muscle and 68 lower, though 27 of the "lower" ones came from skin or blood caught in the sample, not from the muscle itself. The pattern separated every older woman from every younger one.
  • What went up: proteins of the scaffolding around cells (the extracellular matrix, including collagen and elastin), proteins that package DNA in the cell nucleus, and proteins of the lysosome, the cell's recycling centre. Some of these are among the signals released by senescent cells.
  • What went down: enzymes that turn sugar into quick energy, enzymes that handle muscle's sugar store (glycogen), and many proteins of the mitochondria, the cell's power plants.
  • A 24-protein signature. The team chose 24 proteins that changed in the same direction in all ten older women. A combined score of these proteins was strongly linked to a combined measure of grip and walking speed: the higher the score, the weaker and slower the woman.
  • Two stand-outs. Two proteins called HMGB1 and HMGB2, which can act as alarm signals when they leak out of damaged or senescent cells, were higher in all ten older women. They were the signature proteins most strongly linked to poorer function, and they stayed linked even when comparing women within the same age group.

What to keep in mind

  • Very small and a snapshot. The authors list the small, one-time design as the first limitation. Comparing women in their twenties with women over 70 says nothing about when in between, for example around menopause, the changes happen.
  • Optimistic by design. The signature was built and tested on the same 20 women, so the authors expect its performance "is likely optimistic". It needs testing in other, larger groups that include men and people of all ages.
  • Mostly the age gap. Most links between single proteins and function weakened once the age groups were taken into account, so much of the signal reflects the big gap in age rather than differences between women of the same age.
  • Mixed tissue. Biopsies contain varying amounts of blood and connective tissue, and some increases may reflect more blood vessels in the sample. Classic markers of senescent cells were not detected, and the results were not confirmed with a second method, such as staining tissue sections.
  • Links, not causes. The study shows which proteins go with weaker muscles, not which ones make muscles weaker.
  • Not yet peer-reviewed.

Why it matters

Grip strength and walking speed change slowly and depend on motivation and pain as well as on muscle. A protein readout taken from the muscle itself could, once validated, help researchers see whether exercise, diet or drugs aimed at preserving strength are changing the tissue. This small study offers a first candidate for such a readout in women, and points to HMGB1 and HMGB2 as proteins worth a closer look.