With age, women's hearts shrink more than men's, and beat faster to make up for it

Heart scans of nearly 40,000 middle-aged and older Britons showed that the heart's main pumping chamber gets smaller with age in both sexes, but more so in women, whose hearts compensate with a faster beat. Experiments in mice and lab-grown heart tissue point to falling sex hormones. The human data are a one-time snapshot and cannot prove cause.

A high ejection fraction, the share of blood the heart pushes out with each beat, sounds like a good thing. But recent studies have found that people whose main pumping chamber, the left ventricle, is small and squeezes out an unusually large share (more than 65%) are at higher risk of heart problems. Older women are more likely than men to have such hearts. Why that is, and why it would be harmful, has been unclear.

A team at University Hospital Zurich and the University of Zurich combined three very different kinds of evidence: heart scans from almost 40,000 people, experiments in mice, and tiny pieces of heart tissue grown in the lab. Their conclusion: the left ventricle shrinks with age in both sexes, but more in women, and women's hearts make up for it by beating faster. The mouse and tissue work suggest that the decline of female sex hormones plays a part. The human part is observational and was measured only once per person, so it shows links, not causes.

What they did

  • People: the team analysed MRI scans of the heart from 39,616 participants in the UK Biobank, a large British health study, aged 45 to 85. They sorted them into those with heart disease, those with risk factors such as high blood pressure or diabetes, and 19,765 people with neither. Heart volumes were scaled to body size.
  • Mice: 118 mice, half of them female, had their ovaries or testes removed at four weeks of age, or a sham operation. This mimics the loss of sex hormones. Their hearts were scanned when they were young (4–6 months) or old (18–20 months). The team also measured the activity of the sympathetic nervous system, the "fight or flight" nerves that speed up the heart, with a PET scan.
  • Lab-grown tissue: small balls of human heart muscle cells (made from stem cells) and fibroblasts, the cells that make connective tissue and scar tissue, were pushed towards scarring with a signalling molecule, with or without female or male sex hormones.

What they found

  • Hearts got smaller with age in both sexes, especially in people without heart disease or risk factors. Women had smaller chambers than men at every age, even after allowing for body size, and the decline with age was steepest in healthy women, significantly more than in men.
  • Women's heart rate rose more with age. In healthy people, resting heart rate went up with age more in women than in men. Smaller chambers went with faster heart rates in both sexes. Because of this, the amount of blood pumped per minute (scaled to body size) fell less with age in women than in men.
  • Small hearts and very high ejection fractions became more common in older women. Fewer than 1% of people overall had a very small heart, but among women over 76 it was 3%. Among women aged 66 to 75, 4.5% had an ejection fraction above the normal range. In men these shares stayed fairly stable.
  • In women, the sex hormone oestradiol fell with age; in men, testosterone barely changed.
  • In mice, the sex difference was larger. Old females had smaller chambers, more collagen (a sign of scarring), a faster heart rate (438 versus 377 beats per minute) and more sympathetic nerve activity than young females; in males these changes were small or absent. Removing the sex organs early made young mice look more like old ones, so the age differences largely disappeared.
  • In the lab-grown tissue, both female and male sex hormones protected heart cells from dying and reduced scarring.
  • People with heart disease did not follow the same pattern: for instance, their heart rate did not rise with age.

What to keep in mind

  • One snapshot per person. The authors note that the human data cannot prove cause and effect, and that survivors who reach old age tend to be healthier, which may hide part of the age effect.
  • Mostly white, middle-aged and older Britons; ethnic differences could not be studied.
  • The links in people were modest in size, and the analyses were exploratory, without correction for testing many measures.
  • Sympathetic nerve activity was measured only in mice, under anaesthesia, which lowers the heart rate.
  • The lab-grown tissue does not age and lacks the rest of the body; its donors' ages were not matched between the sexes.
  • Lifestyle may play a part: the authors mention that boys often start exercising earlier than girls, which could influence heart size.
  • The study did not measure heart attacks, heart failure or deaths; the link between small hearts and poor outcomes comes from earlier research.

Why it matters

The study suggests that a very high ejection fraction in older women may not be a sign of a strong heart, but of a small heart working harder to keep up. The authors argue that small heart size should be considered a possible risk feature and studied further. They mention possible approaches, including drugs such as beta-blockers, exercise and hormone therapy, but this study did not test any of them; the drugs and hormones are prescription treatments with side effects.