In the very old, more fast-twitch thigh muscle went with more daily activity and a steadier walk
Thigh muscle taken at autopsy from 236 people who died at an average age of 92 showed that those who had been more active had a larger share of fast-twitch fibres, and a larger share went with better walking. An observational preprint, so it shows links, not causes.
Muscles are made of two broad kinds of fibres. Type I or slow-twitch fibres work steadily for a long time without tiring, which suits posture and endurance. Type II or fast-twitch fibres contract quickly and powerfully but tire sooner; they matter when you need to catch your balance, climb a step or speed up. How these fibres change in very old age, and how that relates to walking, has been hard to study, because taking muscle samples from living older people is invasive and is rarely done in large numbers.
A team at Rush University Medical Center in Chicago used another route: thigh muscle donated after death by people who had been tested for years while alive. The study is a preprint, meaning it has not yet been peer-reviewed, and it is an observational study: it can show links, not causes.
What they did
The participants belonged to the Rush Memory and Aging Project, which has followed older people living in their own homes or retirement communities around Chicago since 1997. Everyone agrees to yearly check-ups and to donate their brain and other tissues, including muscle, when they die.
The researchers looked at the first 236 people whose thigh muscle had been examined. They died at 91.7 years on average, and 72% were women. Thin slices of the front thigh muscle were stained so that slow and fast fibres glowed in different colours, and software measured how much of each slice was made of type I fibres, type II fibres, mixed fibres, and everything else (blood vessels, fat and connective tissue).
These measurements were compared with two things recorded during life: daily physical activity, from a sensor worn on the wrist for 10 days, and a walking test (walking 8 feet and turning around twice), timed and with steps counted. The brains were also examined for the changes behind dementia.
What they found
- Slow fibres dominated. On average, about 41% of a muscle slice was type I fibre, 22% type II fibre and 37% other tissue.
- Men had more fast-fibre area, mainly because their type II fibres were bigger, not more numerous. Older age at death went with smaller fibres but not fewer of them.
- More active people had more fast-fibre area. Comparing a typical very active person (about 113 minutes of walking a day, in the sensor's terms) with a typical inactive one (about 8 minutes), the share of type II fibre area was 4.8% larger in the active person. The link held after accounting for vascular disease, back and joint pain, and dementia.
- More fast-fibre area went with better walking. In a statistical model, shifting 15% of the muscle area from fast to slow fibres was linked to a worse gait score, by about a quarter of the usual spread of scores between people (a quarter of a standard deviation). This seemed to be about the relative number of fast fibres, not their size.
- Muscle adds to the brain's share. Brain damage of the kinds seen in dementia explained 5.8% of the differences in walking between people; muscle make-up explained another 3.2% on top.
What to keep in mind
- One snapshot, links only. The authors note that the cross-sectional design "precludes causal inference". Being more active may preserve fast fibres, but people with more fast fibres may also simply find it easier to be active.
- Measured before death, sampled after. Activity and walking were last measured a median of about a year and a half before death. Mobility in the final months, when inactivity can shrink fast fibres, was not known.
- A narrow group. Nearly everyone was in their nineties or late eighties, almost all were non-Latino white, and they were more educated than average. Results may differ in younger or more diverse groups, and in muscles other than the thigh.
- No detail on exercise type. The sensor measured overall movement, not what kind of exercise people did.
- Small shares explained. Most of the differences in walking between people remain unexplained by either muscle or brain.
- Not yet peer-reviewed.
Why it matters
Studies of declining mobility in old age have mostly looked at the brain. This one shows, in a relatively large group for this kind of work, that what the muscle is made of also tracks how well very old people walk, separately from brain damage. It fits the idea that fast-twitch fibres, which help with balance and quick movements, are worth keeping, but it cannot show that activity is what keeps them.